Terahertz

  • Home
  • Archives
  • About
  • Top Posts
    • Top Comments
  • Bookshelf
    • Cosmic Fingerprints
  • Blogrolls
    • Progressive Bloggers
    • The Atheist Blogroll

Ryan represents

Ian | 30 September, 2008 | 23:11

Two new media appearances to report, both are by Ryan Bromsgrove, the UAAA VP-Internal.

First, on Friday, he appeared on CJSR campus radio on the first fifteen minutes show Q Transmissions to discuss the vandalism that happened to the UAAA large banner.

Ryan Bromsgrove on Q Transmissions

Second, in the Gateway today he wrote a reply to the last letter (that called me a hypocrite):

Beliefs must earn respect

In response to Sheila Kwasek’s letter (re: “Secularism no different from religious preference,” 25 September), I would like to address several of her points.

First, the idea that if one does not respect religious beliefs, one can’t be described as in favour of tolerance and equality, is nonsense. Religious beliefs shouldn’t be respected by default; they should earn respect, like everything else. You wouldn’t respect the belief that invisible pink unicorns routinely stampede down HUB. Does that mean you’re intolerant of the unicorn believers? No, you just think that they are wrong, that’s all.

Second, she notes that Canada doesn’t have separation of church and state, like the US does, but “more of a notion that one religion should not be given preference or predominance in a public institution.” What’s the difference? It seems she is arguing semantics here.

Then she claims that forcing secular ideals is somehow no better than forcing religious ideals. This too, is nonsense. Religious ideals demand belief in some deity for which we have no evidence. Secular ideals are, by definition, universally inclusive. If you want to augment your secular ideals with religious ideals, you’re free to, and the rest of us are free not to. Indeed, it’s difficult to see how secular ideals could not be a fundamental part of freedom itself. If you think that it’s somehow unfair to promote secular beliefs and values above religious beliefs and values, you’re frankly wrong.

Finally, calling on someone’s personal fault, whether real or imaginary, in an attempt to discredit their arguments, is entirely unrelated to whether or not their arguments are sound. Sorry, Jesus, better luck next coming.

Ryan Bromsgrove
Science II

Categories
Atheism, Media, Religion, School, UofA Atheists and Agnostics
Comments rss
Comments rss
Trackback
Trackback

« Reflecting on Roy So close to change »

One Response to “Ryan represents”

  1. I ought not to say such things | All Reason says:
    28 October, 2008 at 18:12

    [...] had taken. This was further clarified later in the week when another member of my club’s exec appeared on campus radio to discuss the [...]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

CAPTCHA Image CAPTCHA Audio
Refresh Image

Recent Posts

  • Curing cynical skepticism 6 – Diversifying the skeptical market
  • Curing cynicial skepticism 5 – Building positive communities
  • Harper: Just plain lucky?
  • Curing cynical skepticism 4 – The wrong spin
  • Curing cynical skepticism 3 – The cynical skeptics

PhysCoast T-Shirts

Categories

Alberta Anti-choice Atheism BC Bible Books Canada Capitalism Carnival CFI Charity Communism Companies Computers Conservaspam Conservatives Conspiracy theories Cosmic fingerprints Creationism Cynical skepticism Drugs Economics Edmonton Elections EngPhys Evolution Feminism Free speech FSM Fun Garrison's World Gay rights Global Warming Greens Gritspam Health Care Homeless Humanism Israel Ivory Tower Atheism Liberals Links Logic Media Motivational Poster movies Music NDP Olympics Orientation Parody Personal Philosophy Photonics Briefs Physics Pirate Party Poetry Politics Porn Random Religion Research Scepticism School Science Scientology Secularism SFU Site The Peak UASU Uncategorized UofA UofA Atheists and Agnostics USA Useful Vancouver Video Wildrose Alliance

Political Compass


Recent Comments

  • Michel F on Curing cynical skepticism 6 – Diversifying the skeptical market
  • kirbycairo on Harper: Just plain lucky?
  • ck on Harper: Just plain lucky?
  • Curing cynical skepticism 2 – The non-active atheists | Terahertz on I’m not buying it Gary
  • The Celebration of Light kicks off! on Canada Day Fireworks from Edmonton

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter
    Progressive Bloggers

    Blogging Canadians

    Canadian Blogosphere

    Top Canadian Blogs - Top Blogs

    Subscribe to posts

    Subscribe to comments

    rss Comments rss valid xhtml 1.1 design by jide powered by Wordpress get firefox