Terahertz

  • Home
  • Archives
  • About
  • Top Posts
    • Top Comments
  • Bookshelf
    • Cosmic Fingerprints
  • Blogrolls
    • Progressive Bloggers
    • The Atheist Blogroll

Reflecting on Roy

Ian | 30 September, 2008 | 17:36

A few people have criticized Claudette Roy’s performance last night so far.

But here’s the thing I’m starting to wonder about: Claudette didn’t take any real swings at Linda Duncan. She didn’t take too many as she stuck to her policy mainly, but she did try to frame the debate as between the Liberals and Conservatives. She also aligned herself and the Liberal party as a centrist party (which it is), and I think she was hoping to appeal to fiscal conservatives in the audience.

So I’m thinking there’s a different strategy going on here in the Liberal camp.

I heard a bit of groaning from the NDP when Roy was chosen to run – namely she has the Order of Canada and a strong history of advocating for French rights in the area – and the NDP was hoping that the Liberals would choose a weak candidate so Linda could sail to victory.

But what if instead of choosing a weak candidate that just made the Liberals look bad in this riding (and never have a chance in the future), they are specifically using Roy to target Jaffer’s votes – while leaving Linda’s and the left-wing votes alone.

The Liberals here likely already know that they can’t win here, but rather than run someone who fights for the votes on the left (and gets a couple), what about putting a Liberal who will go after a few hundred to a thousand votes from Jaffer? Also, shifting her politics to the right and ignoring the left for Linda allows a few more of those who voted red last election to shift to the NDP camp this time (as the strategic and only real choice on the left).

Now, I’m not sure if this is why they chose Roy or how they’re running their campaign, but every little advantage brings this riding one step closer to a progressive future.

Categories
Elections, NDP, Politics
Comments rss
Comments rss
Trackback
Trackback

« Edmonton Strathcona All Candidates Forum Ryan represents »

2 Responses to “Reflecting on Roy”

  1. Idealistic Pragmatist says:
    1 October, 2008 at 04:59

    Oh, Roy’s camp is definitely trying to go after Linda. Have a look at the literature her campaign is passing out in this election–it’s really anti-NDP! And they’re also trying to make it sound like they actually have a chance to win by talking about “aggregate totals” over the past so and so many elections (without mentioning that their vote has been decreasing in Edmonton-Strathcona over five elections). Their clear goal is not to lose even more ground, period, no matter what that takes. If she didn’t attack Linda enough in the University debate, it’s only because she had her hands full just reading off her party’s policy, not because of any strategy.

    I think it’s not really fair to call her a weak candidate all around, though. I think Roy is the candidate they could get, given the fact that they got less than 10,000 votes last time with a much higher-profile candidate. She’s still got plenty of credentials (they’re really playing up that Order of Canada) and has some clout within the party. And she’s female, which helped reach their leader’s goal of having lots of women to run for them. She just isn’t a good speaker. It could be a lot worse, believe me.

    Reply
  2. Edmonton-Strathcona Garneau Candidates Forum | Terahertz says:
    8 October, 2008 at 23:55

    [...] Roy responded by distinguishing her party as the “Liberal party is a party of the centre.” [...]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

CAPTCHA Image CAPTCHA Audio
Refresh Image

Recent Posts

  • Iggy said two good things
  • I’m a Canadian Atheist
  • Calm before the storm
  • Muslims run unchecked in Canada?
  • Pride 2010

PhysCoast T-Shirts

Categories

Alberta Anti-choice Atheism BC BCHA Bible Books Canada Capitalism Carnival CFI Charity Communism Companies Computers Conservaspam Conservatives Conspiracy theories Cosmic fingerprints Creationism Cynical skepticism Drugs Economics Edmonton Elections EngPhys Evolution Feminism Free speech FSM Fun Garrison's World Gay rights Global Warming Greens Gritspam Health Care Homeless Humanism Islam Israel Ivory Tower Atheism Liberals Links Logic Media Motivational Poster movies Music NDP Olympics Orientation Parody Personal Philosophy Photonics Briefs Physics Pirate Party Poetry Politics Porn Random Religion Research Scepticism School Science Scientology Secularism SFU Site The Peak UASU Uncategorized UofA UofA Atheists and Agnostics USA Useful Vancouver Video Wildrose Alliance

Political Compass


Recent Comments

  • nike free run on Muslims run unchecked in Canada?
  • Do children of ignorant parents have a chance? on Wind Concerns Ontario, and the sun doesn’t?
  • student aid on Muslims run unchecked in Canada?
  • Ian Andreas Miller on I’m a Canadian Atheist
  • Tay Tay on Foundation for a better life?

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter
    Progressive Bloggers

    Blogging Canadians

    Canadian Blogosphere

    Top Canadian Blogs - Top Blogs

    Subscribe to posts

    Subscribe to comments

    rss Comments rss valid xhtml 1.1 design by jide powered by Wordpress get firefox